Skip to content
Witch on the Holy Night Unofficial game wiki
Guides

Witch on the Holy Night Anyone Can Sleep Walkthrough Guide

Unlock steps, trophies, and PSNProfiles choices for Anyone Can Sleep But Not Laugh in Witch on the Holy Night. This site has not verified the route in-game.

Updated

Checklist graphic for unlocking the Anyone Can Sleep comedy mystery extra
Extra title
Anyone Can Sleep, But Not Laugh
Genre in sources
Comedy mystery; laughter triggers exaggerated deaths
Choices in main game
None; this extra is the only branched section
True ending trophy
The Culprit Is Here
Bad endings trophy
Legendary Detective Kumari (all bad endings)

Spoiler note: This extra is a locked-room comedy mystery. The decision list below names characters and quotes investigation lines. Scene labels elsewhere on this site can hint at plot turns. Stop here if you want zero setup spoilers.

The labeled Decision A through Z list comes from the PSNProfiles trophy guide. No one on this wiki has replayed the extra to check each line in the game. Kannagi’s Japanese walkthrough says more than one option combination can clear the mystery; only decisions V and Y match exactly between those two guides. Treat the table as one published route, not a guaranteed only solution.

What this extra is

The PSNProfiles trophy guide describes Anyone Can Sleep, But Not Laugh as a comedy mystery set in the Kuonji mansion, where laughing leads to exaggerated deaths. The main 13-chapter story has no dialogue choices; PSNProfiles calls this Archive story the only section with player choices and multiple endings. The same guide says it is the longest extra and that all extras together are roughly half the length of the main novel.

After unlock, the game reportedly warns players who just finished the main campaign to save this story for later. Other Archive entries and chapter trophies are on chapters and extras unlock order.

How to unlock the extra

Both PSNProfiles and Kannagi list the menu path Extra → Archive.

Step Requirement Source
1 Finish the main 13-chapter story PSNProfiles
2 Read Seven Days of Spinning (unlocks after Chapter 1 or 2) PSNProfiles; Kannagi
3 Read The Honey Adventure (unlocks after main completion) PSNProfiles; Kannagi
4 If the story still does not appear, read other Archive entries until it unlocks PSNProfiles

Seven Days of Spinning ties to trophy The Town's Story. The Honey Adventure ties to Honey-Glazed Meat.

Clearing the true ending here also gates The Wonderful World of Ploys parts 5 and 6. Platinum planning is on trophy and achievement checklist.

Trophies tied to endings

Trophy Condition Source
The Culprit Is Here Complete Anyone Can Sleep, But Not Laugh on the true ending PSNProfiles; GameFAQs trophies
Legendary Detective Kumari View all bad endings in the same extra PSNProfiles; GameFAQs trophies

PSNProfiles and Steam both list 27 trophies or achievements total. Steam hides most achievement names until unlocked.

Bad endings, rewind, and saves

The PSNProfiles author found nine bad endings. They note that options are not always one-to-one with outcomes, so different dialogue can still land on the same failure.

On PS4, the guide documents holding a specific rewind control during a bad end. Switch, Steam, and mobile button names were not in the checked guides.

The same guide suggests saving before a fork, playing out a bad ending, waiting until the game returns to Archive, then reloading a manual save. Returning to Archive triggers an autosave, so reload only after you are back in the menu.

Multiple solutions

Kannagi states that several option combinations can finish the mystery and that any one route is fine. It publishes one example route among many.

Topic PSNProfiles Kannagi
Decision V Select the third character, Soujyuro Sizuki Same character pick
Decision Y Select the seventh character, Kojika Kumari Same character pick
Decisions A through U, W, X, Z Full English list below Different wording; multiple routes acknowledged

If a line from the table below already failed once, Kannagi’s note on alternate combinations still applies.

PSNProfiles decision list (one published route)

Wording below is the PSNProfiles guide’s English phrasing, not confirmed against live in-game UI on this site.

Wording is copied from PSNProfiles, with apostrophes and dashes tidied. In decision K, PSNProfiles prints "Ritsuka story" without the 's; the table adds it to match decisions I and J. Decision Z reads "now-because" there.

Decision Pick recorded by PSNProfiles
A 1. Might be an ill omen.
B 3. I'll do something random.
C 2. Curious. I should check it out.
D 1. The rain's going to get worse.
E 2. The numbers are off.
F 2. Something crazy's about to go down.
G 1. It was some kind of bread.
H 1. I think we should focus on Tokitsu's death.
I 2. Aozaki's story doesn't add up.
J 1. Sizuki's story doesn't add up.
K 3. Ritsuka's story doesn't add up.
L 2. We should check Riddell's alibi.
M 1. I'll go peek into the hallway.
N 2. Sounds dangerous.
O 2. We should focus on how the phone line was cut.
P 2. It's best to wait for all three to return.
Q 2. Come to think of it, Beo...
R 2. I'm not sure about that.
S 1. Between 2:00PM and 4:00PM?
T 1. A-As long as I lock the door... but I won't be able to sleep!
U 2. Should try to guess who the killer is.
V Select the third character, Soujyuro Sizuki
W 3. Are there two types of murders?
X 2. Who could activate a Ploy?
Y Select the seventh character, Kojika Kumari
Z 3. I'm sure now — because everything happened the way I decided it should.

Decision Q’s “Beo” refers to Lugh Beowulf in walkthrough context. PSNProfiles counts characters by picker slot, not story introduction order.

Session checklist from guides

Phase Action Source
Pre-check Finish main story; read Seven Days of Spinning and The Honey Adventure PSNProfiles unlock chain
Backup Save before the first choice PSNProfiles bad-ending reload tip
True ending pass Use the table above for The Culprit Is Here PSNProfiles
Trophy cleanup Find remaining bad endings for Legendary Detective Kumari Nine endings per PSNProfiles log
After true end Read Ploys 5 and 6 in Archive PSNProfiles; Kannagi

PSNProfiles estimates about 30 hours for a full trophy run including every extra. Skip settings for long rereads are on how long to beat.

Relationship to main chapters

This story appears only after Archive unlock rules fire. Chapter trophies 1 through 13 are reading tasks. Chapters 7 and 8 require reading Martha and Whiteboard first. Details are on chapters and extras.

Choosing a platform or edition does not change these unlock rules. See Steam, Switch, PS4, and mobile versions.

What we could not confirm

  • Exact in-game English strings for each menu line on every port.
  • Whether nine bad endings are exhaustive on every patch (count comes from one PSNProfiles author).
  • Rewind or menu labels on Switch, Steam, or mobile (only PS4 controls are documented in PSNProfiles).

Sources and checking

Unlock steps and decision letters are copied from community guides, not from a fresh playthrough on this site.

Frequently asked questions

How do you unlock Anyone Can Sleep, But Not Laugh?

The PSNProfiles trophy guide says to clear the main story, read Seven Days of Spinning and The Honey Adventure, and keep opening other extras in Archive until this story unlocks.

How many bad endings does the extra have?

The PSNProfiles author logged nine bad endings. The same guide notes options are not always unique, so different picks might hit the same bad end.

Do wrong choices delete progress?

The PSNProfiles guide says a wrong pick sends you to a bad ending and back to the Archive menu. You can rewind with a documented button hold on PS4 or reload a save made before the choice after the game returns to Archive.

Is the PSNProfiles choice list the only solution?

Kannagi Japanese walkthrough states multiple correct option combinations exist. PSNProfiles and Kannagi only agree on decisions V and Y.